Why torture is acceptable
Torture should be allowed torture definitely is a topic that is sensitive to most of the public eye, but it also needs to be talked about torture should be acceptable, only if there is a set reason to use it. Is torture morally wrong at all times and under all circumstances like all absolutist views, this one offers great comfort to its proponents because it absolves them of the necessity of thinking. Why, for example, should torture be restricted to the guilty, if torturing a small number of innocent persons would enable the lives of many other innocents to be saved (as presumably it might) note that on many accounts self defence is a more readily acceptable moral justification or excuse for killing an attacker than is defending the. One question is why (traditional) torture should be so much worse than murder for instance we might think that torture is worse for public choice reasons in such cases toerure might be acceptable, in a counterfactual world in which torture is the only possible way to stop the individual in question from completing the operation in.
The book also discusses the most common forms of torture among them beatings, electric shocks, hanging a person by the limbs, mock executions and forms of sexual assault, especially rape in addition to amnesty international's list, we'll also look at five common forms of torture cited by the boston. This is a highly controversial topic, which is why i'm bringing it to cmv i'd like to propose a scenario a terrorist is apprehended and. Why is torture wrong or more precisely, why is the belief that the torture of captured combatants is wrong compatible with anything other than some form of pacifism i mean this an actual question, not as a passive-aggressive assertion. Torture of sources, by contrast, destroys trust and makes normal interrogation dramatically more difficult, which is why those dictatorships kept their torture confined to political dissidents.
Torture is repulsive even on the scaffold or in front of a firing squad, a man can meet death with dignity the torturer sets out to strip his victim of dignity, to break him, to violate not only. That’s why i favor torture warrants such is the nature and complexity of principled decision-making when confronting the evils of terrorism within the rule of law there are no perfect answers. Torture is also allowed as a form of punishment and when putting people to death rather than prescribing quick methods of execution there were times when muhammad ordered his men to make a victim's death as slow and agonizing as possible. Torture serves no purpose other that to impose pain without purpose imagine you know something i want/need to know you kidnapped my child and at the ransom delivery i captured you. Is torture ever justified in a post-9/11 world frontline gathered a group of legal thinkers to answer this question several of them had studied the torture question together for a joint project.
According to the un convention against torture, any infliction of torture1 i e waterboarding is banned under international law and the domestic laws of most countries in the 21st century. Choppin off daniel pearls head, that was torture, the treatment of the jews in nazi germany, that was torture whatever it is you say is acceptable now, someone will call torture you could put them in 5 star hotels with maids and room service, some jackass will call it torture. It is not morally acceptable to torture rats, unless you have a screw seriously loose unfortunately we experiment on both rats and cats for research purposes i personally don't think we should experiments on cats at all (i confess the idea make. 9 torture is a weapon of those who are too impotent to persuade their point of view they must force their will upon others--torture as a hate device and 10 torture is never acceptable, in any case, no matter what, period. And why there should be no exceptions browse 20+ years of magazine archives and web exclusives subscribers receive full access to the archives.
Are we living in dick cheney’s america all of the numbers say yes first, there’s the new poll from abc news and the washington post, which finds a large and supportive majority for torture. Why torture is never acceptable december 10, 2014 by marcel the facts about the usa using torture on terrorists is now becoming news and as expected, there are many arguing the practice of using torture is not only needed, but morally good. It is rather difficult to determine whether torture is ever acceptable from different points of view, it can be said that each person has his own opinion considering the issue, and this issue is rather contradictive. A signatory to the un convention against torture, the united states does not torture  yet abundant evidence indicates that it does, directly or by proxy—and in fact always has an old american tradition of state-sponsored torture even has its own lexicon: soa, kubark, phoenix, mk-ultra.
Why torture is acceptable
1587 articles torture and the necessity doctrine john alan cohan∗ imagine that you are creating a fabric of human destiny with the object of making men happy in the end, giving them peace. Does the american public condone torture when the goal is to prevent terrorist attacks news headlines reporting the results of a pew research center poll released on dec 9 indicate more than half of americans do. Torture is the act of inflicting severe pain or suffering, mental or physical, on an individual to obtain information, to intimidate or for punishment torture is expressed in many ways, for example, rape, hard labour, electric shock, severe beatings, etc, and for this reason it is considered as.
The reasons why torture is wrong can be divided into reasons of pure principle and reasons based on the bad consequences of torture both sorts of reason are valid torture treats the victim as a. Torture has crept its way back into us mainstream political discourse guantánamo bay also remains open, and donald trump has vowed to keep the prison operational, and to “load it up with some. The use of torture to gain intelligence is never acceptable torture is prohibited under domestic laws of most countries in the international system it is also prohibited under international law. Things that bother me about abrahamic monotheists is the way they torture people to death and set up laws that remove hands and feet, or christians who preach that there is a place of eternal torture for non-christians.
Ten facts to know about torture meeting new people outside irct or outside the circles of human rights work, we’ve found people have a number of questions about what the irct does and, more simply, about the issue of torture around the world.